Scientists Caution About Possible Adverse Effects of Extracting CO2 from the Ocean
We’re losing the battle to manage climate change, prompting many scientists to seek alternative strategies to address the continually increasing global temperatures. Although we’ve proposed several different approaches, many come with extra complications. Recently, researchers have found that one of the most talked-about methods, marine carbon dioxide removal (mCDR), may actually exacerbate the situation by reducing the oxygen levels in the ocean.
The concept behind mCDR aims to enhance the ability of our oceans to sequester carbon dioxide. At present, our oceans serve as the planet’s largest carbon sink, estimated to absorb about a quarter of anthropogenic CO2 emissions. Consequently, numerous experts believe the ocean could play a pivotal role in reversing the effects of human-induced climate change. However, significant challenges remain.
Our oceans are already under strain due to the persistent alterations in our planet’s environment. For instance, the oxygen levels in the ocean are significantly declining. Moreover, a substantial portion of the ocean is becoming deprived of sunlight, further driving down oxygen levels. With rising ocean temperatures, scientists caution that the deeper layers of our oceans will become considerably less effective at circulating oxygen.
This situation will impact marine ecosystems worldwide, resulting in reduced oxygen levels and diminished marine biodiversity. While we have proposed strategies to curb this warming, what if those initiatives could inadvertently worsen the situation? This is the inquiry that new research published in Environmental Research Letters seeks to address. The research team examined various mCDR techniques and discovered that many of them could indeed have detrimental effects.
We’ve devised multiple strategies to mitigate ocean warming. Though these might prevent sea levels from rising, most would necessitate some level of biomass production, leading to sinking organic matter in the ocean. The researchers caution that this would yield unintended consequences for the ocean’s oxygen levels.
One strategy involves essentially fertilizing the ocean by introducing nutrients like iron to encourage phytoplankton growth, like those depicted in the image above. These blooms can absorb more carbon dioxide. Though these organisms would eventually sink and transport the carbon to the ocean floor, they would also consume oxygen as they decompose. Through simulations, the researchers analyzed the effects of 100 years of ongoing fertilization on ocean oxygen levels.
They discovered that over a century, the ocean could experience a reduction of approximately three percent in its oxygen capacity globally. This figure is more than twice the loss attributed solely to global warming. Furthermore, they found that certain regions beneath the fertilized areas could potentially decline by over 50 micromoles, changes that would surpass the deoxygenation observed under high-emission climate scenarios.
This new research illustrates that while we may propose beneficial ideas for the climate, not all of these will be advantageous for the ocean. Our aim, as humans striving to assist our planet, should be to identify the most effective methods to do so without causing further harm. So far, it appears that the majority of mCDR techniques might do more damage than good in the long term. It seems we need to reevaluate our approach.
Read More