Influence of macOS 26 Icon Approach on Mac Users Versus Developers
# macOS Tahoe: Icon Modifications and User Feedback
In discussions surrounding iOS 26, Liquid Glass and clarity have garnered significant attention regarding the iPhone’s software overhaul. Conversely, the updates to app icons on the Mac have elicited strong reactions from macOS Tahoe users. One specific alteration arguably complicates Mac usability.
## Transitioning from Finder to Macintosh HD
The shift began with the app anchored in the first slot of the Dock: Finder. Apple abandoned years of tradition in macOS 26 beta 1 by reversing the standard color scheme of the blue and white Finder face(s) icon. Fortunately, this was corrected in the second developer beta.
More recently, it’s the lesser-seen Macintosh HD icon alteration that has ignited a reaction. In macOS 26 developer beta 5, Apple replaced the traditional icon featuring a detailed spinning platter hard disk drive.
While the icon was visually appealing, the metaphor became outdated when Apple transitioned to solid state drives. However, by that rationale, it could be deemed equally unreasonable to utilize a vintage telephone glyph for the Phone icon, but let’s not delve too deeply into this.
To enhance accuracy, Macintosh HD should ideally be labeled as Mac SSD or Apple Drive since it’s not actually a hard disk drive. I’m not inclined to support modernizing the name for fear of losing the final official reference to the Mac’s complete title.
There are two primary grievances that resonate regarding the new Macintosh HD icon.
Firstly, Mac users find it perplexing why the drive features holes. The USB-C shaped hole is somewhat logical, but the three headphone jack-shaped holes appear merely decorative rather than functional. Of course, a more literal Mac disk icon would resemble a computer chip rather than resembling a typical Samsung external SSD — but with holes.
The second common piece of feedback is the inconsistency in the perspective of the drive icon compared to the Apple logo. The drive is angled to display the top and front, while the Apple logo seems to depict the drive viewed from directly above.
I must admit, my initial response was “oh, cool, Apple should market that as an external SSD,” but then I remembered, Apple’s internal SSD upgrade costs are enough to deter me.
## Mac Users Can “Adjust” Drive Icons
The Macintosh HD icon issue isn’t as pronounced as the Finder change, however.
For one, the Mac operating system does not show Macintosh HD on the desktop by default as it did in earlier versions. Thus, only users who opt to display it on the desktop will see it. You can toggle its visibility from Finder’s Settings panel.
macOS also permits customization of any drive icon, including Macintosh HD, so you can always keep the previous icon and revert if nostalgia strikes.
Conversely, Finder is permanently on the Dock and cannot be tailored by the user.
## Some Users Experience Blurry Icons
Aside from Finder and Macintosh HD, the Mac operating system does share some of the clarity discussions related to Liquid Glass on iOS and iPadOS. This is attributed to the glass layer effect employed on many of Apple’s app icons that are largely unified with those on the iPhone and iPad now.
While these icons appear more striking when enlarged, the intricate designs can seem blurry when reduced to practical sizes. The degree of blurriness largely depends on how effectively the icon can be perceived by the observer.
Someone with exceptional vision may manage to discern the level of detail at smaller sizes. I’ve never had stellar vision, and I’m certainly among those who view Apple’s new icon style as somewhat unclear and straining to the eyes.
Apple’s initial attempt at the Photos app icon was the most egregious, although boosting the saturation improved it in recent betas. The most unfortunate occurrences, for me, involve the automatic modifications Apple is implementing on third-party app icons.
## Apple’s Gray Box Strategy Affects Mac Users
Apple aims to motivate developers to refresh their app icons for the new layered glass aesthetic. macOS Tahoe also confines every icon into a uniform squircle shape. App icons that utilize a different squircle or fall outside the boundaries of a rounded square are relegated to a gray box.
As with iOS 26, macOS Tahoe automatically applies a layered glass appearance to select third-party app icons. Slack and iA Writer are two examples within my Dock. Slack could benefit from a saturation boost to appear less blurry to me, and perhaps that adjustment will occur post-beta. Apple’s Numbers app icon also seems blurry and not at Retina quality due to the automatic effect, but hopefully, it will be refined when iWork apps receive updates for macOS 26.
Regarding the gray box that
Read More