If You’re Seeking the Most Features, the Fenix 8 Clearly Prevails
Garmin remains at the forefront of durable smartwatches with the introduction of the Garmin Instinct 3 and the Garmin Fenix 8. Although both are designed for outdoor lovers and athletes, they appeal to various types of users and price points. If you desire the most extensive feature set, the Fenix 8 distinctly excels—but that doesn’t imply that the Instinct 3 lacks its own advantages.
Let’s explore what positions the Fenix 8 as the premier adventure smartwatch and how it measures up to the more budget-friendly Instinct 3.
Design and Display: Upscale vs. Functional
The Fenix 8 is a high-end device in every regard. It boasts a sleek construction of steel or titanium, protective sapphire or Gorilla Glass, and a vibrant AMOLED touchscreen. Available in several sizes (43mm, 47mm, and 51mm), the Fenix 8 provides options for varying wrist sizes and style choices. It also accommodates various bands, such as metal, leather, and nylon, rendering it appropriate for both rough use and formal occasions.
Conversely, the Instinct 3 features a fiber-reinforced polymer and aluminum build, imparting a more practical appearance. It’s lighter (59g versus up to 74g for the Fenix 8) and available in eye-catching colors like Neo Tropic and Electric Lime. Although it now includes an AMOLED display—a significant enhancement from older models—it lacks touchscreen capability, depending instead on physical buttons.
Winner: Fenix 8 for its high-quality materials, touchscreen, and adaptable design options.
Hardware and Performance: Fenix 8 Takes the Edge
In terms of processing power and storage, the Fenix 8 stands apart. It is equipped with 1GB of RAM and 32GB of storage, allowing users to save maps, music, and a variety of workouts. It also includes Wi-Fi support for quicker syncing and software updates.
The Instinct 3 operates with a basic ARM Cortex M4 processor, featuring only 17MB of RAM and 4GB of storage. This restricted capacity means no offline maps or GPX exports, and users may need to be cautious with storage to install updates or save workouts.
Winner: Fenix 8 for its enhanced processing capabilities and storage space.
Health and Fitness Features: Enhanced Sensors, Greater Insights
Both devices provide a thorough array of health sensors, including heart rate monitoring, SpO2 detection, skin temperature, and multi-band GPS. However, the Fenix 8 is equipped with Garmin’s latest Elevate v5 heart rate sensor, enhancing accuracy and adding ECG functionality. It also features unique sensors such as an ambient light sensor and a depth gauge for diving.
On the software front, the Fenix 8 offers sophisticated training resources like Garmin Coach, rucking mode, hydration tracking, ski maps, and strength training capabilities. The Instinct 3 provides fundamental features but is missing many of these advanced options.
Winner: Fenix 8 for its innovative sensors and extensive software ecosystem.
Battery Life: A Tight Competition
Despite its advanced features, the Fenix 8 provides commendable battery life. Depending on the variant, it can last up to 29 days in smartwatch mode and 13 days with the always-on display (AOD) activated.
The Instinct 3 also performs well in this area, particularly the 50mm version, which offers up to 24 days in smartwatch mode and 9 days with AOD. MIP/Solar versions can even extend battery life further, making the Instinct 3 a strong option for those prioritizing longevity.
Winner: Tie. Both models deliver impressive battery life, with the Instinct 3 slightly ahead in solar-powered variants.
Price and Value: Instinct 3 Excels in Affordability
The Garmin Instinct 3 is priced at approximately $499.99, positioning it as a solid midrange choice for users seeking a robust watch without overspending. It features outstanding battery life, a vibrant AMOLED display, and essential health and fitness tracking.
In contrast, the Fenix 8, priced at $1,199.99, is over double the cost. While the price is justified by its premium construction, advanced sensors, and comprehensive software, it represents a considerable investment.
Winner: Instinct 3 for budget-conscious shoppers.
Final Conclusion: Choose Fenix 8 for Features, Instinct 3 for Value
If your main focus is to have every feature Garmin offers—offline maps, touchscreen, ECG, advanced training tools, and an upscale design—the Fenix 8 is the indisputable choice. It’s the optimal option for dedicated athletes, adventurers, and tech enthusiasts seeking the ultimate smartwatch experience.
However, if you prefer a dependable, rugged, and durable watch that meets the basics at a significantly lower price point, the Instinct 3
