# 5 Films That Critics Misjudged Beyond Belief
Critique of films is inherently subjective, and at times, critics fall short. Whether due to herd mentality, personal preferences, or simply becoming weary from viewing too many movies, critics sometimes miss the mark. Here are five films that, regardless of their critical evaluation, have gained a cherished place in the hearts of audiences or have proven their lasting appeal.
## 1. **The Super Mario Bros. Movie (2023)**
**Critics’ Score:** 59%
**Audience Score:** 95%
Let’s begin with a straightforward choice. *The Super Mario Bros. Movie* was a lively, colorful, and entertaining interpretation of the legendary video game series. Despite the critics’ tepid response, audiences embraced it wholeheartedly. Featuring a remarkable cast, including Jack Black as Bowser, the film successfully captured the spirit of the cherished games. It didn’t aspire to be an artistic masterpiece but achieved its goal of providing a fun, uplifting experience that struck a chord with fans.
## 2. **Hook (1991)**
**Critics’ Score:** 29%
**Audience Score:** 76%
Steven Spielberg’s *Hook* received harsh criticism, yet for many, it remains a treasured childhood favorite. Featuring Robin Williams as Peter Pan and Dustin Hoffman as Captain Hook, the film was enchanting and steeped in nostalgia. While Spielberg has voiced regrets about certain elements, the film wasn’t crafted for critics but for children who still believed in magic. In that respect, it was a tremendous triumph.
## 3. **Tommy Boy (1995)**
**Critics’ Score:** 42%
**Audience Score:** 90%
*Tommy Boy* was yet another comedy that critics failed to appreciate upon its release, yet it has since attained cult status. The dynamic between Chris Farley and David Spade delivered comedic brilliance, and the film’s blend of humor and heartfelt moments has endeared it to viewers. Critics may have labeled it as “silly,” but fans recognized the charm and wit that made it a beloved movie.
## 4. **The Last Jedi (2017)**
**Critics’ Score:** 91%
**Audience Score:** 42%
*The Last Jedi* stands out as one of the most polarizing entries in the *Star Wars* saga. Critics lauded it for its daring and unconventional approach, yet numerous fans felt disillusioned. The depiction of Luke Skywalker as a cranky hermit, Leia’s moment in space, and several questionable narrative decisions left fans feeling disconnected. While it’s not the most disappointing *Star Wars* film, it certainly failed to meet the high hopes of its fandom.
## 5. **The Secret Life of Walter Mitty (2013)**
**Critics’ Score:** 52%
**Audience Score:** 71%
*The Secret Life of Walter Mitty* aspired to convey a deeper message than the other films on this list. Ben Stiller’s portrayal of Walter Mitty, a dreamer who embarks on a magnificent journey, was inspiring and visually breathtaking. The film’s theme of stepping outside one’s comfort zone and truly embracing life resonated with many viewers, even if critics didn’t fully recognize its artistic and emotional significance.
—
These movies are a testament to the fact that critics do not always wield the final judgment. Occasionally, films resonate with audiences in ways that surpass critical evaluations, resulting in them being celebrated as timeless classics. Whether it’s the nostalgia of *Hook*, the humor of *Tommy Boy*, or the adventure of *The Secret
