New Study Offers Understanding on Why Comet 3I/Atlas Is Improbable to Be Extraterrestrial

New Study Offers Understanding on Why Comet 3I/Atlas Is Improbable to Be Extraterrestrial

3 Min Read


several analysts suspected that 3I/ATLAS was of alien origin. However, a recent publication may shed light on the true nature of this peculiar object. Spoiler alert: It probably isn’t extraterrestrial.

Submitted to the Research Notes of the AAS, the study compares the behavior of 3I/ATLAS to other comets traversing our solar system, associating its unusual flight paths with a phenomenon known as outgassing, which can alter speed, rotation, and orbital trajectory. The paper’s author, Marshall Eubanks, stated that the team assessed the object’s non-gravitational acceleration using two interplanetary spacecraft. The findings, according to Eubanks, indicated that the object exhibited typical behaviors of other comets moving through our solar system.

This paper largely dispels months of conjecture, during which a contingent of Harvard astrophysicists theorized that 3I/ATLAS could be a fragment of extraterrestrial technology. Avi Loeb, a Harvard astrophysicist, even entertained the idea on the Joe Rogan podcast after publishing a draft paper on the topic in July 2025. Concerns heightened in late December when astronomers noted that the comet was emitting an unusual radio signal. However, this isn’t the first occasion that Loeb and others have raised the alien possibility in recent times. For instance, in 2017, the comet Oumuamua passed through the solar system displaying comparable traits. This time, though, interplanetary spacecraft enabled astronomers to perform innovative experiments, measuring the comet’s non-gravitational acceleration without tracking multiple orbits. Therefore, the comet’s legacy may serve as a glimpse into the makeup of distant solar systems, rather than evidence of visitors from beyond.

An interstellar guest?

3I/ATLAS has intrigued the scientific community since its detection by the Asteroid Terrestrial-impact Last Alert System (ATLAS) survey telescope in Rio Hurtado, Chile, in July 2025. Due to its course and velocity, ATLAS concluded that the comet came from beyond our solar system, marking it as only the third recorded interstellar object of this type. Featuring a substantial icy core that scientists estimate to be between 1,400 feet and 3.5 miles in diameter, the comet is enveloped by a luminous cloud of dust and gas, referred to as a coma. Following a hyperbolic path, which means it is traveling too quickly to be captured into a closed orbit around the sun, the comet achieved a peak velocity of 153,000 mph as it traversed beyond Mars’ orbit in October 2025.

The speculation that 3I/ATLAS might be an interplanetary, extraterrestrial visitor stemmed from these remarkably distinctive characteristics, particularly its unusual flight pattern. Based on Avi Loeb’s publication – titled “Is the Interstellar Object 3I/ATLAS Alien Technology?” — the comet’s trajectory is exceedingly unlikely, navigating a path that brushes unusually close to Venus, Jupiter, and Mars, which Loeb’s team assessed would only happen 0.005

You might also like