Harrison Ford’s involvement with science fiction is notable, but that’s what happens when you portray the scruffy nerf herder Han Solo and outshine the likes of Jack Nicholson, Paul Newman, and Sean Connery for a role in “Blade Runner.” Although the iconic actor has often downplayed the cinematic legacies he contributed to, they undeniably solidified the career he enjoys today. Nevertheless, looking back, there’s one sci-fi amalgamation that had all the necessary elements to become a wildly successful venture yet instead turned out to be a box-office disappointment of cosmic proportions.
In 2011, Ford joined forces with Daniel Craig, Olivia Wilde, and Sam Rockwell in the Jon Favreau-directed comic book adaptation, “Cowboys & Aliens.” At this juncture in his career, Favreau was thriving, having laid the groundwork for the Marvel Cinematic Universe through his direction of “Iron Man” and “Iron Man 2” in 2008 and 2010. Shifting focus to another section of the comic book realm, “Cowboys & Aliens” was based on a 2006 sci-fi Western, casting Craig as a memory-impaired outlaw who, alongside a rancher (Ford), must defend themselves against extraterrestrial threats armed with far more than just revolvers. Unfortunately, despite the potential for a thrilling adventure, viewers didn’t fully resonate with the film, primarily due to the stiff competition it faced.
Cowboys & Aliens struggled at the box office
With a production budget of $163 million, “Cowboys & Aliens” barely managed to cover its costs, earning around $176 million at the box office, according to The Numbers. The film faced fierce rivalry upon its release in late July 2021, with Chris Evans debuting as the iconic superhero in “Captain America: The First Avenger” — a universe Ford would later join – and losing the top position to “The Smurfs.” This was also the week preceding our introduction to the chest-thumping leader, Caesar (Andy Serkis) in “Rise of the Planet of the Apes,” adding to the robust competition.
Even when sharing the same timeframe as Smurfs and intelligent apes, “Cowboys & Aliens” failed to impress critics. It garnered a mere 44% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, with Time Out stating, “what began as ‘True Grit’-meets-‘War of the Worlds’ ultimately resembles — dare we say it — ‘Wild Wild West.'” Slate also viewed the film as a squandered chance, remarking that, “it’s amusing to consider what ‘Cowboys & Aliens’ could have been had any creativity ventured beyond the title page.”
While Ford attempted another foray into science fiction two years later with the similarly received “Ender’s Game,” by 2015 he would return to his roots with “Star Wars: Episode VII – The Force Awakens,” which remains his most successful film to date. This demonstrates that, despite all the film’s flaws, the nerf herder is truly all we require.